Reverse osmosis system
Back to Articles
Drinking Water9 min read

Reverse Osmosis vs. Other Drinking Water Filters: Which is Best?

Compare RO systems to carbon filters, UV purification, and pitcher filters. Learn what contaminants each removes and which is right for your water quality concerns.

With so many water filtration options available, choosing the right one can be overwhelming. The best choice depends on what contaminants you need to remove and how you want to use the filtered water.

How Reverse Osmosis Works

Reverse osmosis (RO) is the most thorough water purification method available for home use. It forces water through a semipermeable membrane with pores so tiny that only water molecules can pass through.

This process removes dissolved solids, heavy metals, bacteria, viruses, and a wide range of contaminants that other filtration methods simply can't address. Modern RO systems typically include multiple pre-filters and post-filters for comprehensive treatment.

What RO Removes

Total dissolved solids (93%+)
Lead and heavy metals
Arsenic
Nitrates and nitrites
PFAS/PFOA ("forever chemicals")
Fluoride
Chlorine and chloramines
Bacteria and cysts

Filter Type Comparison

Different filtration methods are designed to address different contaminants. Understanding what each type removes helps you make an informed choice.

Reverse Osmosis

Removes:

TDS 93%+LeadArsenicNitratesPFASFluorideSodium

Pros:

  • Most thorough purification
  • Removes dissolved solids
  • NSF certified

Cons:

  • Produces waste water
  • Slower flow rate
  • Higher initial cost

Carbon Filter

Removes:

ChlorineTaste/OdorSome VOCsSome pesticides

Pros:

  • Fast flow
  • Low cost
  • Easy to install

Cons:

  • Doesn't remove dissolved solids
  • Doesn't remove nitrates
  • Doesn't remove fluoride

Pitcher Filter

Removes:

Chlorine tasteSome leadSome mercury

Pros:

  • Very low cost
  • No installation
  • Portable

Cons:

  • Limited effectiveness
  • Frequent filter changes
  • Small capacity

When to Choose RO

Reverse osmosis is the best choice when you need the purest possible drinking water, particularly if your water contains:

High TDS - If your water has high dissolved solids (over 500 ppm), RO is the only effective solution

Nitrate contamination - Common in agricultural areas, nitrates are only removed by RO or specialized ion exchange

PFAS concerns - These persistent chemicals require RO or specialized activated carbon for removal

Lead or arsenic - RO effectively removes these toxic metals that other filters may miss

Tankless vs. Traditional RO

Traditional RO systems store purified water in a pressurized tank, while tankless systems produce water on demand. Each approach has advantages:

Traditional (Tank) RO

  • Immediate access to stored water
  • Lower upfront cost
  • Tank takes up space
  • Water can taste stale

Tankless RO

  • Fresh water every time
  • Compact design
  • Better water efficiency
  • Higher flow rates

Installation and Maintenance

Most RO systems install under the kitchen sink with a dedicated faucet. Professional installation ensures proper connections and optimal performance.

Maintenance typically involves replacing pre-filters every 6-12 months and the RO membrane every 2-3 years. Modern quick-change filters make this simple enough for most homeowners.

The Bottom Line

For the purest drinking water possible, reverse osmosis is unmatched. If you're primarily concerned with chlorine taste or have relatively clean municipal water, a simpler carbon filter may suffice.

A water test reveals exactly what contaminants are present, allowing you to choose the right level of filtration for your specific water quality concerns.

Find the Right Drinking Water Solution

Get a free water test to determine which filtration system is best for your water quality.